A few days ago, a friend transferred an e-mail he had just received. Sender: a law firm established in Switzerland. The message, obviously preformatted, accuses him of using a photograph retrieved from Google Images on his site, and asks him about 1,300 €. This was not an isolated misunderstanding: it is a very real phenomenon, which is growing.
I'm not looking for an excuse from my friend. It's been a long time since I told him to stop taking pictures without rights. But this story deserves to be stopped, because it says something about how the right of photographers is applied today.
A mail that has nothing to do with craftsmanship
After consulting a lawyer, my friend realized that he was dealing with a company specializing in the automatic tracking of photographs, which sends mass complaints. This is not an anecdote: the same pattern has been described for several years by lawyers.
The best-known example in France is PicRights, a Swiss company mandated by agencies such as AFP, Reuters or Associated Press. According to lawyer Simonnet, image recognition software browses the web, tracks correspondence and generates bulk notices, without consideration on a case-by-case basis. Amounts requested range from 300 to 2,000 € With a delay of 14 days, tens of thousands of letters were sent to France. An article published in May 2026 by the Justice Village also describes a fully automated chain: algorithmic detection, standardized mail, transmission to partner firms. The recipients are mostly very small companies, independents, associations or bloggers.
The phenomenon is not specific to news agencies. A survey by Computer Weekly and Süddeutsche Zeitung, published around November 2020, reported on how a German photographer was chasing users of his photos with automated tools under a Creative Commons license whose credit was incorrect. The amounts ranged from a few hundred euro to much heavier claims, and several courts, including the Zurich Commercial Court in May 2020, wronged the photographer.
Why it's summing up
This is not a proof, but a personal observation: the more the tools of image detection and automated sending improve, the more the cost of sending a mail falls to zero. When a message costs almost nothing to produce, only a few recipients pay for the transaction to be profitable. I cannot confirm that artificial intelligence is the source of the mail received by my friend; What is documented is the automation of detection and sending.
What the law says, and what it doesn't say
Let's start with what's certain: a photo found on Google Images is not free of rights. Google Images only index images already online, and find one does not give permission to reuse it. A photograph is protected as soon as it is created, without formality, and framing the image or citing its source does not render its publication lawful. Under French law, infringement is punishable, at the most, by three years' imprisonment and 300,000. € (Article L.335-2 of the Intellectual Property Code).
Then there is an important nuance. In France, a photo is protected by copyright only if it is original, i.e. if it reflects the creative choices of its author: framing, light, angle, processing. Several recent decisions have given rise to a number of defendants on this point, such as the Rennes Court in January 2026 for a press photo whose composition was largely dictated by the event.
When the judges convicted, the amounts were inconvenient with the amicable claims. In Paris, in June 2024, the company prosecuted had to pay about 580 € for parasitic behaviour, without conviction for forgery, for lack of originality of the photo. In Marseille, in December 2024, a company was sentenced to 800 € and 800 € of procedural costs, the photo being considered original. According to the lawyers cited, these letters are mainly a threat rather than a trial: out of tens of thousands of letters, only two judgments are recorded in France following PicRights' findings.
All this does not mean that we can use ourselves freely. Behind each image is a photographer who worked, and some claims are perfectly legitimate.
If you receive such mail
I am a photographer, not a lawyer: this is not legal advice. This is what the lawyers recommend, whose analysis I have read.
- Do not pay in the rush and do not respond to hot.
- Remove the image if you do not have the rights.
- Don't recognize anything in writing: sentences like « I didn't know. » or « I used this photo in good faith » have, in practice, strengthened opposing files.
- Check that the image matches the one claimed, and if you had a license.
- Consult an intellectual property lawyer if the amount is high or if you operate a commercial site.
The simplest solution: buy or order your images
If you need photos, you have two healthy ways. Either you buy images under license from a image bank by reading the conditions (some free licenses impose a specific credit, and an error may be enough to make them obsolete). Either you call on a photographer from your area.
The second option has an advantage that the image banks do not give: you leave with a single picture, which really belongs to you, realized for your activity, your property or your boat. And you will never have to fear the mail from a firm across Europe.
Photographer and telepilot of drone in Nice, I make photos and videos for professionals and individuals. Do not hesitate to contact me: we will see together what you need.
Are you professional and want to exchange links between our sites or collaborate?
Sources
- Simonnet Counsel, « Courrier PicRights (AFP, AP, Reuters): how to react? »
- Village of Justice, « PicRights against the French judge » (5 May 2026)
- Into The Minds, « PicRights + AFP : a well-rounded trolling copyright operation » (judgements of Paris, Lille and Marseille, 2024)
- Moderator's blog, « Using an image found on Google to illustrate content: is that legal? »
- Computer Weekly, « Automated image recognition: how using "free" photos on the internet can lead to lawsuits and fines »
- EERV, « Right to image » (2026)